On Christmas Eve 2018, the S&P 500 closed almost 20% below its autumn peak. The Nasdaq 100 was down 23%. Markets shut for Christmas the next day. Many people spent the holiday wondering whether a bear market had just started.
That's the fear going around right now. The numbers explain why.
On 16 November 2018, the Nasdaq 100 was down 9.8% for the quarter. On Tuesday, it closed down 11.2%.
Tech is tracking 2018 almost to the day. The Fed is hiking into year-end as well.
Inflation is running hotter than it was then.
But the rest of the market doesn't fit. Eight of the 11 S&P 500 sectors are up this quarter. In 2018, at the same point, only three were.
What I found
The Nasdaq 100 is on 2018's path: down 11.2% this quarter against 9.8% at the same point in 2018.
The rest of the market isn't: 8 of 11 sectors are up, against 3 of 11 in 2018.
The macro is worse than in 2018. Core inflation is running at 3.7%, and real yields are nearly three times higher, so the Fed has less room to step in.
A 2018-style December would take the S&P 500 back to its March low, around 6,280.
The tell to watch: in December 2018, the "safe" sectors fell too. Until staples, health care and banks start falling with tech, this stays a tech problem.
Skip ahead: the December checklist is at the end.

How 2018 broke: three legs, with December doing most of the damage
October was the rate scare. Powell said rates were "a long way from neutral". The 10-year yield climbed to 3.24% in early November. The S&P 500 fell about 7% for the month.
November was a fake calm. Democrats won the House, and stocks bounced.
December was everything at once. A US-China truce on 1 December lasted three days before the "Tariff Man" tweet.
On 19 December, the Fed hiked for the fourth time that year and said its balance sheet run-off was on "autopilot".
Then the government shut down. The S&P 500 fell 14.4% between 16 November and Christmas Eve.
Then it was over. Powell turned "patient" on 4 January.
The market rallied about 25% in the next four months.
The part people forget is that nothing was safe in that last leg.
Staples fell 13.1% and health care 12.3%. Once the selling turned forced, the hiding places stopped working.

The rhyme is real this time
The Fed is hiking again. It raised rates in September to 3.75-4.00%.
Futures now price a hike on 9 December at about 95%, in the same month as the 2018 hike. One Fed governor said on Wednesday that a half-point move is probably needed.
Democrats won the midterms. This time they took both chambers. Two days after the vote, the Nasdaq 100 fell 6.4% in a single session on fears that new data centres will be harder to approve.
We are still in a Trade War. New polysilicon duties start on 4 December. The US has just closed loopholes on semiconductor exports to those who rent chips to Chinese companies. Of course, much to the annoyance of Beijing. The US-China trade truce agreed last autumn, which keeps tariffs on both sides lower and Chinese rare earths flowing, now runs only to 10 January.
The macro is worse than 2018
On the numbers the Fed cares about most, 2026 actually looks tougher.
Inflation is hotter. Core inflation rose at a 3.7% annualised pace over the three months to October, against 1.9% in 2018. Headline inflation is about 4% year-on-year, against 2.5%.
Borrowing costs are much higher. The 10-year yield is about 5.1%, against 3.1% in mid-November 2018. After inflation, the 10-year real yield is 2.92%, against 1.06%.

But that inflation difference is the big worry.
In January 2019, Powell could turn quickly because core inflation was about 2%. With core running at 3.7% this time round, a quick Fed rescue is much harder.
If the market cracks this time, the 2019 escape hatch may stay shut.
Luckily, not everything is worse. Tariffs are far higher, around 11% against under 2% of imports in 2018, but they have moved sideways this year.
Unemployment is 4.1%, down from 4.5% a year ago.
High-yield credit spreads have widened to 3.43%, close to their 3.48% high from 5 November, but are still low by any long-run standard.
The surprise: this time investors are rotating out of tech
If the macro is worse, why is the S&P 500 holding up better? It's down 4.0% this quarter, against 5.8% at the same point in 2018.
The sectors explain it.

Defensives are leading by even more than in 2018. Staples are up 13.5% this quarter, utilities 10.1% and health care 10.0%. Investors are clearly nervous.
But the economy-sensitive sectors are up too. Discretionary, the shops-and-spending sector, is up 7.6%. In 2018, it was down 9.3% by this point.
Financials are up 6.9%, against a 2.9% fall in 2018. Energy and materials are up as well.
The damage is in one corner. Technology is down 16.6% this quarter, and chip stocks are down 24.4%. In 2018, those two had fallen 9.5% and 11.4% by mid-November.
So 2018 was a broad growth scare that hit banks, shoppers and energy together. 2026, so far, is a tech unwind with the money moving into the rest of the market.
The tell: shoppers are holding up
When investors fear a recession, they sell companies that need a strong economy and buy those that don't. The cleanest gauge is discretionary against staples.
That ratio has fallen 5.2% this quarter. By mid-November 2018, it had fallen 12.7%, more than twice as far.

One caution. Over the past three months, discretionary has lagged staples by 7.7 points, close to 2018's 8.0.
Industrials have trailed the S&P 500 by 6.4 points as AI build-out names cracked. The consumer looked shakier in late summer than it does now, so this is worth checking every week.
The verdict: two different answers
You're right to worry about the setup. The macro is worse than in 2018. It leaves the Fed less room to rescue the stock market.
But sector performance suggests the market is pricing in an AI problem. A recession isn't priced in. A 2018-style growth scare would show up in banks and shoppers first. Both are up this quarter.
So my answer splits in two.
Tech: a 2018-style December is a live risk. It could be even worse. The Nasdaq 100 is already on the 2018 path. Chips are down far more than in 2018. Real yields are higher too. A hawkish Fed on 9 December would hit tech hardest.
The broad market: a full 2018 repeat looks unlikely unless the rotation breaks. For that, staples, health care and banks would have to start falling with tech, as they did in December 2018.
What would a repeat look like? The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq 100 each fell about 14% between 16 November and Christmas Eve 2018.
The same move from Tuesday's close would take the S&P 500 to about 6,280 (SPY near $627) and the Nasdaq 100 to about 23,130 (QQQ near $563).
That is right back at the 30 March lows from the oil shock.
SPY's March low was $631.97 and QQQ's was $558.28. A 2018-style December would wipe out the whole rally since spring.

History leans against the worst case for the broad market.
Of the seven midterm years since 1998, 2018 is the only one where the S&P 500 fell in the fourth quarter. The other six averaged a 9.4% gain.
Since 1950, the S&P 500 has been higher 12 months after all 19 midterm elections. The average gain was 15.1%.
Even 2018 ended up 11.7% a year after the vote.

Keep this: the December 2018 checklist
The 2018 recipe comes back if:
The Fed hikes on 9 December and signals more for 2027, or goes by half a point.
The 10-year yield breaks above its 5.31% October high.
Oil spikes again on trouble around the Strait of Hormuz.
High-yield spreads push clearly above 3.48%, the 5 November high. They are at 3.43% now.
China retaliates for the chip rule, or the US-China trade truce ends on 10 January without a new deal. If it ends, China's extra tariff on US goods jumps from 10% to 34% and its curbs on rare-earth exports come back.
The sector tell: staples, health care and banks start falling alongside tech. That is the moment rotation turns into broad selling.
QQQ closes below its 5 November low of $647.05. It closed at $656.95 on Tuesday, 1.5% above it.
The recipe stays on the shelf if:
A December hike comes with a clear signal to pause.
Core inflation cools back toward 0.2% a month.
Discretionary keeps holding up against staples.
Chips find a floor while the rest of the market keeps rising.

Watch 9 December. In 2018, that was the FOMC meeting that turned a correction into a crash.
If you know someone who still remembers Christmas Eve 2018 a little too well, send this to them. And if you want the checklist handy for December, bookmark this page.
DISCLAIMER: This newsletter is intended for educational purposes only. Any information or analysis in this note does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any securities. Nothing in this note is intended to be investment advice, nor should it be relied upon to make investment decisions. Any opinions, analyses, or probabilities expressed in this note are those of the author as of the note's date of publication and are subject to change without notice.